Integrated Framework to Assess Advanced Phosphorus Recycling as a Sustainable Alternative to Sewage Sludge in Agricultural Soils

Abstract

Advanced phosphorus (P) recycling from wastewater is critical for improving nutrient circularity and reducing soil pollution associated with the direct application of sewage sludge in agriculture. However, few studies evaluate the long-term environmental and economic trade-offs between recycled P products and raw sewage sludge application. This study compares struvite, vivianite, and dicalcium phosphate (CaP) as P alternatives to sludge to mitigate heavy metal accumulation in Spanish agricultural soils. Using data from 27,835 plots, heavy metal accumulation was simulated over 50- and 100-year fertilisation scenarios. The results indicate that continuous sludge application leads to widespread exceedances of zinc, copper, and cadmium, especially in alkaline soils, whereas substitution with recycled products can substantially reduce these risks. Vivianite balances P recycling and costs, CaP offers the best environmental performance but with higher investment, and struvite suits smaller regions prioritising environmental safety. Economic analysis favours advanced recycling over sludge, especially considering externalities such as soil remediation costs. Despite limitations, our findings emphasise the importance of integrating environmental externalities into economic assessments and the value of advanced P recycling for sustainable soil management.